brew tea

Which Zisha Clay Teapot Suits Your Tea? A Seven-Clay Brewing Comparison

Which Zisha Clay teapot Suits Your Tea? A Seven-Clay Brewing Comparison

As the old saying goes, “The vessel is the father of tea.” Among tea vessels, the Zisha (purple clay) teapot has long held a special place because it “neither steals the fragrance nor produces a cooked-soup taste.” The Ming dynasty tea master Xu Cishu already put it clearly in Cha Shu (Tea Notes): Zisha is made from coarse sand precisely because the sand has no earthy smell; it does not rob the tea of its aroma or create a “cooked soup” flavor, so the tea keeps its original taste, with color, aroma, and flavor all preserved.

That is the core strength of Zisha: the material itself has no earthy or muddy odor that would interfere with the objective expression of a tea’s aroma and taste. This is also why Zisha teapots have remained popular for centuries. But in the market there are many mainstream Zisha clays, Ben Shan Lv Ni, Zi Ni, Duan Ni, Di Cao Qing, Xiao Hong Ni, Zhu Ni, Hong Jiangpo Ni, and others. Because different clays shrink and densify differently, they can naturally affect how the same tea expresses its flavor.

To find out how large that difference really is, the Siyutao team carried out a systematic comparative brewing test using different Zisha clays. The test used 30-mesh Hong Jiangpo Ni; 40-mesh Huanglongshan Di Cao Qing, Zi Ni, Ben Shan Lv Ni, Xiao Hong Ni, and golden-yellow Duan Ni; and whole-sieve raw-sand Zhu Ni. All teapots had the same 100 ml capacity.

Generally, the lower the mesh number, the larger the clay-particle gaps, and the more visible the sandy texture. This brings better breathability and heat dissipation, which can help with the micro-exchange between tea soup and air and with “waking” the tea. The test covered green tea, yellow tea, white tea, black tea, oolong tea, raw Pu’er, and ripe Pu’er (dark tea). Purified water was used throughout, and brewing times were set according to tea evaluation practice and common daily brewing, with suitable times for each tea type.

So how big is the flavor difference when the same tea is brewed in different Zisha clays? Which clay is more compatible with the tea on your table? Here are the round-by-round results.

Method at a glance

  • Clays tested: 30-mesh Hong Jiangpo Ni; 40-mesh Huanglongshan Di Cao Qing, Zi Ni, Ben Shan Lv Ni, Xiao Hong Ni, golden-yellow Duan Ni; whole-sieve raw-sand Zhu Ni.

  • Teapot capacity: 100 ml for all.

  • Water: purified water.

  • Evaluation: color, aroma, and taste, combining tea-review standards with everyday brewing times.

  • Teas: green, yellow, white, black, oolong, raw Pu’er, and ripe Pu’er.

Green tea: Huangshan Maofeng

Green tea is all about freshness. The sample was Huangshan Maofeng, brewed with 3 g tea in 100 ml water at 100°C; first infusion 1 minute, second infusion 1.5 minutes.

Most clays produced attractive liquor color: Ben Shan Lv Ni was pale tender green and bright; Zi Ni, Duan Ni, Di Cao Qing, and Xiao Hong Ni were tender green and bright; Zhu Ni was yellowish-green and fairly bright; Hong Jiangpo Ni was green and fairly bright.

The taste differences were clearer. Ben Shan Lv Ni and Xiao Hong Ni best brought out Huangshan Maofeng’s tender fragrance, and their freshness and sweetness were close. Ben Shan Lv Ni had an advantage in a lofty aroma with floral notes and a more refreshing, sweet-crisp liquor. Duan Ni followed with a clear, lofty aroma, noticeable tender fragrance, and a fresh, sweet-crisp taste. Zhu Ni and Di Cao Qing both showed fairly lofty aroma; Zhu Ni was purer in aroma, and their liquor body was similar. Zi Ni and Hong Jiangpo Ni ranked lower: Zi Ni’s aroma was slightly dull, and its liquor was fresh but not fine enough; Hong Jiangpo Ni was mellow but coarse in texture.

Ranking: Ben Shan Lv Ni > Xiao Hong Ni > Duan Ni > raw-sand Zhu Ni > Di Cao Qing > Zi Ni / Hong Jiangpo Ni.

Best for tender green tea: Ben Shan Lv Ni and Xiao Hong Ni.

Yellow tea: 2023 Huang Xiaocha

The yellow tea sample was a 2023 Huang Xiaocha (small-leaf yellow tea), brewed under the same conditions.

Liquor color differed little among clays; only Di Cao Qing and Zhu Ni produced a relatively deeper yellow-bright color, while the other five showed a pale yellow-bright quality.

In aroma, Zi Ni was the most noticeable; Ben Shan Lv Ni showed a pure aroma; Duan Ni and Xiao Hong Ni were medium; Di Cao Qing, Zhu Ni, and Hong Jiangpo Ni showed a dull note.

In taste, Ben Shan Lv Ni, Zi Ni, and Duan Ni formed the top tier for fresh, mellow liquor. Di Cao Qing and Xiao Hong Ni were mellow but showed bitterness. Zhu Ni and Hong Jiangpo Ni were more bitter, rougher, and less mellow.

Ranking: Zi Ni > Ben Shan Lv Ni / Duan Ni > Xiao Hong Ni > Di Cao Qing / raw-sand Zhu Ni / Hong Jiangpo Ni.

White tea: 2021 Grade-1 Bai Mudan

The white tea sample was a 2021 Grade-1 Bai Mudan. Different clays had little effect on liquor color. In aroma, Hong Jiangpo Ni showed a slight dull note; the other six clays expressed the downy fragrance (hao xiang). Zi Ni, Ben Shan Lv Ni, and Di Cao Qing showed the most noticeable downy fragrance. Duan Ni, Xiao Hong Ni, and Zhu Ni also showed clear downy fragrance; Duan Ni and Di Cao Qing additionally revealed a clean, elegant floral note, while Zhu Ni had a faint sour hint on close inspection.

In taste, Zi Ni was the strongest: sweet, mellow, with aroma integrated into the liquor. Ben Shan Lv Ni was better suited to younger tea; on this 4-year-aged Bai Mudan it performed similarly to Di Cao Qing. Duan Ni was mellow and thick with a returning sweetness, and the aroma entered the liquor. Xiao Hong Ni, Zhu Ni, and Hong Jiangpo Ni showed more flaws, either bitterness or insufficient thickness and layering.

Ranking: Zi Ni > Ben Shan Lv Ni (better for young tea) / Di Cao Qing > Duan Ni / Xiao Hong Ni / raw-sand Zhu Ni / Hong Jiangpo Ni.

The seven clays were relatively balanced for Bai Mudan, so drinkers can also choose by personal preference.

Oolong tea: Jiulongke Da Hong Pao

The oolong sample was Jiulongke Da Hong Pao, brewed with 8.33 g tea in 100 ml boiling water; first infusion 30 seconds, second infusion 5 seconds.

Only Xiao Hong Ni produced a slightly deeper orange-yellow liquor; the rest were orange-yellow and bright. Di Cao Qing was the standout of this round: rich, high-floating floral aroma and a thick, mellow taste. The other six clays also expressed Da Hong Pao’s floral aroma. Zi Ni showed a more noticeable floral note; Duan Ni had floral aroma plus a roasted-fire note; Ben Shan Lv Ni, Xiao Hong Ni, Zhu Ni, and Hong Jiangpo Ni all showed fairly clear floral aroma.

In taste, Zi Ni was thick and mellow at entry but slightly astringent; Ben Shan Lv Ni was fairly thick and mellow, and Hong Jiangpo Ni was on the mellow side, but both lacked layering. Zhu Ni, Xiao Hong Ni, and Duan Ni were insufficient in thickness and showed more bitterness and astringency.

Ranking: Di Cao Qing > Zi Ni > Ben Shan Lv Ni / Hong Jiangpo Ni > raw-sand Zhu Ni / Xiao Hong Ni / Duan Ni.

Black tea: 2023 traditional smoky Souchong

The black tea sample was a 2023 traditional smoky Souchong, brewed with 3 g tea in 100 ml boiling water; first infusion immediately, second infusion extended to 1.5 minutes.

All clays produced the expected orange-yellow bright liquor; only Xiao Hong Ni was slightly deeper. Aroma showed a stepwise difference. The top tier was Zi Ni, Di Cao Qing, and Xiao Hong Ni, all with noticeable sweet fragrance and relatively high overall aroma. Ben Shan Lv Ni, Zhu Ni, and Hong Jiangpo Ni followed, also showing clear sweet fragrance. Duan Ni ranked lowest, with only a modest sweet fragrance and the plainest aroma.

In taste, Zi Ni, Xiao Hong Ni, and Zhu Ni all showed sweet, mellow liquor; Xiao Hong Ni stood out for aroma in the soup and richer layering. Di Cao Qing, tied with Zi Ni in second place, was mellow and sweet with good aroma in the soup. Ben Shan Lv Ni, Hong Jiangpo Ni, and Duan Ni were sweet and mellow but either thin, short-lasting, or light.

Ranking: Xiao Hong Ni > Zi Ni / Di Cao Qing > raw-sand Zhu Ni > Ben Shan Lv Ni > Hong Jiangpo Ni > Duan Ni.

Raw Pu’er: 2016 Yiwu aged raw Pu’er

The raw Pu’er sample was a 2016 Yiwu raw Pu’er with 9 years of aging. Brewing was fixed at 3 g tea in 100 ml boiling water; first and second infusions at 1 minute and 1.5 minutes.

Liquor color showed almost no difference; aroma and taste separated the clays. Di Cao Qing had a rich, high-floating aroma, sweet, moist entry, and smoother liquor. Duan Ni followed with a rich, lasting aroma, mellow liquor, and aroma integrated into the soup. Zi Ni and Ben Shan Lv Ni both had fairly strong first-infusion aroma; Zi Ni’s second infusion was more high-floating, with aroma in the soup and a sweeter, moister body. Xiao Hong Ni, tied with Ben Shan Lv Ni in fourth, had a fairly high aroma and mellow, sweet liquor. Hong Jiangpo Ni had relatively high aroma, but its mellow liquor showed a slightly rough, grainy texture. Zhu Ni ranked last: its aroma was slightly dull, the liquor was strong, and it showed noticeable astringency.

Ranking: Di Cao Qing > Duan Ni > Zi Ni > Ben Shan Lv Ni / Xiao Hong Ni > Hong Jiangpo Ni > raw-sand Zhu Ni.

Ripe Pu’er: 2006 Yiwu ripe cake

The final round used a 2006 Yiwu ripe Pu’er cake. Tea amount, water amount, and temperature were the same as for raw Pu’er; because the sample was compressed, the first and second infusions were extended to 3 minutes and 2 minutes.

Liquor color differed little: all seven clays produced red, dense, bright liquor, with Zi Ni and Di Cao Qing slightly deeper. In aroma, all except Ben Shan Lv Ni expressed the aged aroma expected of an old ripe tea. Zi Ni showed the richest aged aroma; Hong Jiangpo Ni was also relatively noticeable; Zhu Ni and Duan Ni were pure; Di Cao Qing was both rich and pure; Xiao Hong Ni was fairly pure.

In taste, Zi Ni was again the most striking: thick, mellow, sweet, moist, with aroma integrated into the soup. Zhu Ni followed with sweet, mellow liquor, soft and smooth. Hong Jiangpo Ni was thick and mellow with good sweetness and moisture. Duan Ni was a step behind. Di Cao Qing and Xiao Hong Ni showed flaws, and Ben Shan Lv Ni failed to express the old tea’s mellow thickness.

Ranking: Zi Ni > raw-sand Zhu Ni > Hong Jiangpo Ni > Duan Ni > Di Cao Qing > Xiao Hong Ni > Ben Shan Lv Ni.

Simple summary table

 Tea type Best match Also strong Less suited in this test
Green tea (Huangshan Maofeng) Ben Shan Lv Ni, Xiao Hong Ni Duan Ni, raw-sand Zhu Ni Zi Ni, Hong Jiangpo Ni
Yellow tea (2023 Huang Xiaocha) Zi Ni Ben Shan Lv Ni, Duan Ni Di Cao Qing, raw-sand Zhu Ni, Hong Jiangpo Ni
White tea (2021 Grade-1 Bai Mudan) Zi Ni Ben Shan Lv Ni (young tea), Di Cao Qing Xiao Hong Ni, raw-sand Zhu Ni, Hong Jiangpo Ni
Oolong (Jiulongke Da Hong Pao) Di Cao Qing Zi Ni raw-sand Zhu Ni, Xiao Hong Ni, Duan Ni
Black tea (smoky Souchong) Xiao Hong Ni Zi Ni, Di Cao Qing Duan Ni
Raw Pu’er (2016 Yiwu) Di Cao Qing Duan Ni, Zi Ni Hong Jiangpo Ni, raw-sand Zhu Ni
Ripe Pu’er (2006 Yiwu cake) Zi Ni raw-sand Zhu Ni, Hong Jiangpo Ni Di Cao Qing, Xiao Hong Ni, Ben Shan Lv Ni

 

Bottom line

Across the seven tea categories, the clays showed clear tendencies:

  • Ben Shan Lv Ni is especially suited to tender green tea, yellow tea, and high-tenderness or younger white tea, helping preserve tender fragrance and downy fragrance while keeping the liquor fresh, sweet, and crisp.

  • Zi Ni is good at expressing the fresh-mellow quality of yellow tea, the sweet-mellow quality of white tea, the thick, mellow, sweet-moist quality of dark tea, and aroma in the soup.

  • Di Cao Qing is particularly effective at drawing out the floral aroma of Wuyi rock oolong and the sweet fragrance of black tea.

  • Xiao Hong Ni performed very well with black tea, with aroma in the soup and richer layering.

  • Duan Ni was reliable for green tea, yellow tea, white tea, and raw Pu’er, though it was less impressive for black tea in this test.

  • Raw-sand Zhu Ni was strong for ripe Pu’er and acceptable for black tea, but less suited to aged raw Pu’er in this round.

  • Hong Jiangpo Ni showed some brightness and aroma, but its texture was often coarser and less fine.

In short, there is no single “best” Zisha clay for every tea. Match the clay to the tea, and to your own taste preference. For tender freshness, start with Ben Shan Lv Ni or Xiao Hong Ni; for aroma and sweetness in black tea, try Xiao Hong Ni; for rock oolong and aged raw Pu’er, Di Cao Qing is worth a first look; for ripe Pu’er and aroma-in-the-soup expression, Zi Ni is a strong candidate.

written by siyutao team

Hinterlasse einen Kommentar

Bitte beachte, dass Kommentare vor der Veröffentlichung freigegeben werden müssen.